1. Nikola,
Hello everybody,
so here is a history of a spades round, with some of my comments:
Note that this is a team game with 4 players, and I will also skip the non interesting tricks:
Of course, I don't expect bots to be perfect at all, but a nill should be very simple and easy to follow and play.
Round #17.
It's Sonic's turn.
Sonic thinks taking 0 tricks this round.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Anastasia thinks taking 3 tricks this round.
It's your turn.
Press B to enter the number of tricks you think you will take in this round.
You think you will take 3 tricks this round.
It's Newby computer's turn.
Newby computer thinks taking 4 tricks this round.
Here it started with a few basic tricks, but the important suits are especially diamonds and spades.
Nikola plays an ace of diamonds.
It's Newby computer's turn.
Newby computer plays a 2 of diamonds.
It's Sonic's turn.
Sonic plays a 5 of diamonds.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Anastasia plays a 3 of diamonds.
Nikola wins the trick.
It's your turn.
Nikola plays a 7 of diamonds.
It's Newby computer's turn.
Newby computer plays a 4 of diamonds.
It's Sonic's turn.
Sonic plays an 8 of diamonds.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Anastasia plays a 10 of diamonds.
Anastasia wins the trick.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Now, the logical thing would of course be that Sonic plays his 8, being that I took out my ace and he could play his highest card.
But, if only that was the end...
Nikola plays a 6 of diamonds.
It's Newby computer's turn.
Newby computer plays a 5 of spades.
It's Sonic's turn.
Sonic plays a queen of diamonds.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Anastasia plays a king of diamonds.
Newby computer wins the trick.
It's Newby computer's turn.
So, as you can see, he plays his lowest card on the ace, but in reality has a queen.
Then, this entire nill is questionable, especially if we look at the spades played:
Newby computer plays a 7 of spades.
It's Sonic's turn.
Sonic plays an 8 of spades.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Anastasia plays a 2 of spades.
It's your turn.
Nikola plays a 10 of spades.
Nikola wins the trick.
It's your turn.
Nikola plays a 10 of hearts.
It's Newby computer's turn.
Newby computer plays a queen of spades.
It's Sonic's turn.
Sonic plays a 9 of spades.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Anastasia plays a 4 of spades.
Newby computer wins the trick.
It's Newby computer's turn.
Newby computer plays an ace of spades.
It's Sonic's turn.
ace of spades, Newby computer
Sonic plays a king of spades.
It's Anastasia's turn.
Anastasia plays a jack of spades.
It's your turn.
Nikola plays a 3 of spades.
Newby computer wins the trick.
I don't understand how the bots are created to understand this as a good nill to play. Not only this, but really playing a nill should be relatively simple to program. All the bot has to do is play the highest cards possible without winning a trick, thus if an ace is on the table, logically play his strongest card of the suit.
In addition to that, play a nill with a king of spades in very rare conditions, especially not with 2 more high spades.
Hopefully their logic of both bidding and playing a nill can be improved in the future.
Resultado: +0